Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Chinese water torture at drug tribunal

No comments:
The ‘updates’ from the AFL’s Anti-Doping Tribunal are more like Chinese water torture than waterboarding.

Today’s hectic proceedings are summarised:

The Australian Football League Anti-Doping Tribunal continued the hearing today relating to the cases of past and present Essendon Football Club players and a former employee of the Essendon Football Club who have been issued with Infraction Notices.

 The tribunal today heard opening submissions by Mr Neil Clelland QC on behalf of two former Essendon players, followed by opening submissions by Mr David Grace QC on behalf of the remaining 32 current and former Essendon players.

Following the opening submissions of the players, the Tribunal heard submissions from the parties on the admissibility of certain evidence to be considered by the Tribunal.

The hearing will continue tomorrow.

The next chapter of the Jason Bourne story it ain’t.
Read More

Monday, January 19, 2015

Bulldogs exodus

No comments:
Chief Executive Simon Garlick is the latest to announce a move from Whitten Oval.

Will the last person to leave please turn out the lights?
Read More

Saturday, January 17, 2015

Saints’ big risk in move from Seaford

No comments:
There are salutory lessons for the Saints, if they’re open to looking.

The Demons have rarely played ‘home’ games away from the famous MCG, but it hasn't been their spiritual home for many years — perhaps since the mid-sixties ground-sharing agreement with the Tigers. Aside from a couple of brief flowerings under John Northey and Neale Daniher, the Demons have been in the wilderness since the 60s. Various training centres and adminsitrative centres have seemed like more band-aids plastered onto a festering wound.

The original Lions, Fitzroy, gave up their traditional home in Brunswick Street for various ground-sharing deals and a shooting star-like rennaissance at the Junction Oval in the 80s. Each move seemed like a step down and back, giving up far more than they gained. By the mid-90s it was all over.

The Hawks spent years playing at Princes Park, turning it into a gold and brown cauldron, but retained their spriritual home at Glenferrie Oval. When they moved to Waverley, it was for the right reasons and for a far superior facility. They've gone from strength to strength and become a powerhouse on and off the field.

More recently, the Barcodes and the Bombers have made strategic moves to new facilities, cutting and loosening, respectively, their ties with their traditional homes. Like the Hawks, it’s hard to see them on the wrong side of the ledger as a result.

But the Saints. From a traditionally-lowly base at Junction Oval, their move to Moorabbin in the mid-60s was one of the first moves away from traditional venues in the VFL. And the Saints prospered on-field with three Grand Final appearances over seven years. Despite indifferent form through the 70s and 80s, bayside was Saints territory.

The Linton Street facility was tired, so a move was needed. It doesn’t seem that Seaford has been everyone’s cup of tea, but it was a bold strategic move for a far superior facility. Talk of a return to Junction Oval or Moorabbin suggests they haven’t embraced the change in the way that the Hawks embraced theirs.

The Kangaroos haven't broken many records on membership, but the Shinboner spirit remains strong and Arden Street keeps that spirit strong. Similarly, despite few on-field successes, the Bulldogs and Whitten Oval are synonymous (despite the players shooting themselves in the foot over their coach at the end of the 2014 season).

Forget about Moorabbin or the Junction Oval, Saints. Embrace Seaford and move heaven and earth to make it the embodiment of everything you aspire the club to be. Location isn't a deal-buster. The Hawks have shown that outer suburbs can work, and it’s firhgtening how many Geelong fans live on the opposite side of the Bay from Sleepy Hollow.

Don't pine for something else. Make Seaford a fortress for the Saints brand. Own it.
Read More

Wednesday, January 14, 2015

Nonsense speculation

No comments:
Reports today of the appointment of Taylor Walker as Captain for the Crows include the rider that the return of Patrick Dangerfield to Victoria is now almost a sure bet.

Implicit in this nonsense that masquerades as ‘sports journalism’ is the notion that Dangerfield, as the Crows’ best player, should be Captain.

It’s fair to say there’d be some debate over who is the Crows’ best if both players are at their best. Dangerfield is an exquisitely talented midfield bulldozer and Walker an exquisitely talented marking and leading forward. Which is best? Who cares!

The bigger point that this speculation chooses to ignore is the inner sanctum’s assessment, behind closed doors, of which is the more appropriate leader on and off the field. The Captaincy isn’t a talent quest. Captaincy is about the best leader, not the best player.

Perhaps the best example of this in recent times was Nick Maxwell, Premiership Captain of Collingwood. Another was Tom Harley, Premiership Captain of Geelong.

The coaching staff in Adelaide have made an assessment. If Dangerfield packs up his little red wagon and rushes back to Victoria at the first opportunity, perhaps they’ve made the right call.
Read More

Chinese water torture at drug tribunal

The ‘updates’ from the AFL’s Anti-Doping Tribunal are more like Chinese water torture than waterboarding.

Today’s hectic proceedings are summarised:

The Australian Football League Anti-Doping Tribunal continued the hearing today relating to the cases of past and present Essendon Football Club players and a former employee of the Essendon Football Club who have been issued with Infraction Notices.

 The tribunal today heard opening submissions by Mr Neil Clelland QC on behalf of two former Essendon players, followed by opening submissions by Mr David Grace QC on behalf of the remaining 32 current and former Essendon players.

Following the opening submissions of the players, the Tribunal heard submissions from the parties on the admissibility of certain evidence to be considered by the Tribunal.

The hearing will continue tomorrow.

The next chapter of the Jason Bourne story it ain’t.

Bulldogs exodus

Chief Executive Simon Garlick is the latest to announce a move from Whitten Oval.

Will the last person to leave please turn out the lights?

Saints’ big risk in move from Seaford

There are salutory lessons for the Saints, if they’re open to looking.

The Demons have rarely played ‘home’ games away from the famous MCG, but it hasn't been their spiritual home for many years — perhaps since the mid-sixties ground-sharing agreement with the Tigers. Aside from a couple of brief flowerings under John Northey and Neale Daniher, the Demons have been in the wilderness since the 60s. Various training centres and adminsitrative centres have seemed like more band-aids plastered onto a festering wound.

The original Lions, Fitzroy, gave up their traditional home in Brunswick Street for various ground-sharing deals and a shooting star-like rennaissance at the Junction Oval in the 80s. Each move seemed like a step down and back, giving up far more than they gained. By the mid-90s it was all over.

The Hawks spent years playing at Princes Park, turning it into a gold and brown cauldron, but retained their spriritual home at Glenferrie Oval. When they moved to Waverley, it was for the right reasons and for a far superior facility. They've gone from strength to strength and become a powerhouse on and off the field.

More recently, the Barcodes and the Bombers have made strategic moves to new facilities, cutting and loosening, respectively, their ties with their traditional homes. Like the Hawks, it’s hard to see them on the wrong side of the ledger as a result.

But the Saints. From a traditionally-lowly base at Junction Oval, their move to Moorabbin in the mid-60s was one of the first moves away from traditional venues in the VFL. And the Saints prospered on-field with three Grand Final appearances over seven years. Despite indifferent form through the 70s and 80s, bayside was Saints territory.

The Linton Street facility was tired, so a move was needed. It doesn’t seem that Seaford has been everyone’s cup of tea, but it was a bold strategic move for a far superior facility. Talk of a return to Junction Oval or Moorabbin suggests they haven’t embraced the change in the way that the Hawks embraced theirs.

The Kangaroos haven't broken many records on membership, but the Shinboner spirit remains strong and Arden Street keeps that spirit strong. Similarly, despite few on-field successes, the Bulldogs and Whitten Oval are synonymous (despite the players shooting themselves in the foot over their coach at the end of the 2014 season).

Forget about Moorabbin or the Junction Oval, Saints. Embrace Seaford and move heaven and earth to make it the embodiment of everything you aspire the club to be. Location isn't a deal-buster. The Hawks have shown that outer suburbs can work, and it’s firhgtening how many Geelong fans live on the opposite side of the Bay from Sleepy Hollow.

Don't pine for something else. Make Seaford a fortress for the Saints brand. Own it.

Nonsense speculation

Reports today of the appointment of Taylor Walker as Captain for the Crows include the rider that the return of Patrick Dangerfield to Victoria is now almost a sure bet.

Implicit in this nonsense that masquerades as ‘sports journalism’ is the notion that Dangerfield, as the Crows’ best player, should be Captain.

It’s fair to say there’d be some debate over who is the Crows’ best if both players are at their best. Dangerfield is an exquisitely talented midfield bulldozer and Walker an exquisitely talented marking and leading forward. Which is best? Who cares!

The bigger point that this speculation chooses to ignore is the inner sanctum’s assessment, behind closed doors, of which is the more appropriate leader on and off the field. The Captaincy isn’t a talent quest. Captaincy is about the best leader, not the best player.

Perhaps the best example of this in recent times was Nick Maxwell, Premiership Captain of Collingwood. Another was Tom Harley, Premiership Captain of Geelong.

The coaching staff in Adelaide have made an assessment. If Dangerfield packs up his little red wagon and rushes back to Victoria at the first opportunity, perhaps they’ve made the right call.