Friday, February 26, 2016

Not missing score review

No comments:
We're watching the Cats and Barcodes going around on the second weekend of preseason, and it just occurred to us that something is missing.

The concept of having every scoring decision correct  isn't a bad one, but when it means a minute or more of slow motion replay it becomes a needless distraction.

It has been noticeable (eventually) that the game is not being interrupted to check every close goal line decision. It took time to notice it was missing because it's rarely really necessary through the home and away season.

Let's just get rid of the distraction and let the goal umpires make their decision.



Read More

Tuesday, February 23, 2016

All, or nothing at all

No comments:
According to The Age's chief football writer, "The embarrassing oversight that has seen Alastair Clarkson not once named the AFL's coach of the year has led to a policy change by the games's coaching body."

Why is it embarrassing? Sure, his team has won three AFL Premierships on the trot — a not insignificant achievement — but should a premiership automatically qualify Clarkson to win the award? Should Clarkson get the gong if the Hawks finish ninth this year, as some sort of compensation?

We checked on the AFLCA website and here is the current basis for coaches voting on their peers for this award:

Allan Jeans Senior Coach of the Year AwardThis award is in recognition of the best performed Senior Coach throughout the home and away season, having regard for current season's performance, available resources, player talent and team management.
And here are the winners since the inauguration of the award (with Premiership coaches identified):
2015 - Luke Beveridge (Western Bulldogs)
2014 - John Longmire (Sydney)
2013 - Ken Hinkley (Port Adelaide)
2012 - John Longmire (Sydney)  Premiership
2011 - John Worsfold (West Coast)
2010 - Michael Malthouse (Collingwood)  Premiership
2009 - Ross Lyon (St. Kilda)
2008 - Mark Thompson (Geelong)
2007 - Mark Thompson (Geelong)  Premiership
2006 - John Worsfold (West Coast)
2005 - Neil Craig (Adelaide)
2004 - Mark Williams (Port Adelaide)  Premiership
2003 - Paul Roos (Sydney)

Those last three criteria seem to be quite reasonable for assessing the best coach for the year. If the award is for the best-performed coach of the year, you'd choose the Premiership coach almost every year.

So, on the basis of the season's performance, available resources, player talent and team management, Luke Beveridge was chosen, by his peers, as the Coach of the Year.

It all seems perfectly logical and not even faintly embarrassing to us.
Read More

Monday, February 22, 2016

One week down

No comments:
AussieRulesBlog has been lucky enough to see all but one of this first week's games via our pay-TV service. Our initial view that the game had changed has been vindicated.

These are practice games and most teams will be holding something in reserve. Nevertheless, the standard has been good mostly with all teams giving fans something to look forward to. For some it was a competitive quarter by a young group, for others a commanding win.

The key takeout is the change in tackling mentioned in a previous post. Interestingly, while catching the replay of the Brisbane–Gold Coast game tonight, Jonathan Brown and Cameron Mooney made the same point in commentary. In the past, they said, players were taught to try to hurt an opponent, by driving a shoulder into their ribs, or driving their opponent's shoulder into the turf. So far in 2016, we've noticed one fairly gentle 'sling'-type tackle. The tacklers' objectives seem to be simply to hold the ball carrier up and to try to win the holding the ball or incorrect disposal free kick. Old players are wistful for those 'harder' times, but we think this is an especially good development.

The other key thing we've taken note of is the attacking nature of the games, generally from both sides. There's nothing more than pride riding on the result, so there's no incentive for coaches to close these games up to stem scoreboard bleeding. It will be interesting to review the style of play in the first home and away round and see if the attacking style remains in vogue.

It's tough to look too closely at this week's games and extrapolate to a full season, but AussieRulesBlog thought the Tigers were the least impressive team. Their disposal was poor for a club that has aspirations to go deep into finals. They'll look better against teams less well-drilled than the Hawks, but our view of Richmond has long been that they reward mediocrity. This week's game did nothing to suggest they won't be afflicted with the same problem in 2016.

All in all, though, isn't it great to have some footy back?
Read More

A hard road for a giant

No comments:
Much bleating on social media and elsewhere about the week’s holiday being offered to Docker giant, Aaron Sandilands, but the MRP are following a well-established practice.

Sandilands can’t be blamed for being head and shoulders above the rest of the competition, at least in stature, but he erred on two counts. Firstly, Griffiths wasn’t his ruck opponent, and second, having chosen to bump, he (Sandilands) bears the responsibility for even coincidental high contact or injury.

It must be hard being that tall. There are probably less than a handful of opponents he can legitimately decide to bump without being in danger of high contact.

It goes without saying that there will be MRP decisions that will perplex and mystify, but this isn't one of them. Enjoy your week off, Aaron.
Read More

Thursday, February 18, 2016

A noticeable change

No comments:
Watching the opening game of the 2016 pre-season tonight, one thing stood out — the change in tackling intention. It might be that the umpiring department have got onto something that will improve the game we watch every week.

In the lead-up to the game, it was made quite clear, though the media, that the umpires would strictly police slinging tackles. AussieRulesBlog sees that as a real plus, but we were prepared to be disappointed.

In recent years, the objective of tackling has seemed to be to force the opponent into the ground with as much force as could be mustered. Almost inevitably, we saw sling tackles and players, unable to protect or brace themselves, being slammed into the ground. A few concussions resulted in a so-called 'double movement' sling tackle becoming a reportable offence — but that didn't stop the intent to slam players into the turf.

Tonight's first pre-season game was played at a pretty good pace for a the first competitive practice game, with plenty of physical clashes. For all of that, the intention when tackling seemed to be to win a free kick for holding the ball or incorrect disposal, rather than to knock the opponent into next week. There were no sling-type tackles that we saw.

It was a refreshing change, and one that we hope to see repeated as we see more games.

There’s plenty for Blues fans to like from Brendan Bolton’s first outing as head coach, while Sam Mitchell looked not to have missed a beat from the Grand Final. It’s great to have footy back!
Read More

A not-so-steep price tag

No comments:
At first glance, Mick Malthouse’s reported $1 million price tag to manage the twelve suspended Bombers (and three at other Melbourne clubs?) for the 2016 season is a steep one. If Paul Little steps in and picks up the tab, it's a no-brainer. But even if the players funded it themselves, there's more upside than down.

While there’s plenty of precedent for players missing a year of football and returning successfully, they’re generally within the bosom of their club, with all of the benefits, and psychological and social advantages, of team elan.

Those banned from their teams, and from competitive sport, for a year are far fewer — Ahmed Saad, Lachie Keefe, Josh Thomas and Ryan Crowley.

Saad had a one-year rookie contract with the Saints following his suspension, but was then delisted and not drafted by another AFL club. Keefe and Thomas have been listed as rookies for 2016 by the Barcodes following their year suspended. Crowley was set to resume his football in the WAFL after failing to be drafted following his year away from the game, but was the first player signed by Essendon when topping up their list after the CAS decision. (Being the first player signed was, in all likelihood, more a matter of availability than desirability.)

Saad’s career at AFL level appears to be finished. Keefe and Thomas will be playing VFL in 2016 and hoping for elevation to the senior list and a contract for 2017 and beyond — but nothing is certain. Only Crowley, courtesy of the unusual circumstances at Essendon, will have an immediate chance to put his case on-field for continuing his career.

It's hard to imagine that Dyson Heppell, for instance, won’t be welcomed back into the Bombers’ fold with open arms in 2017. The question will be how far below the Dyson Heppell of 2015 he’ll be in late 2016 when pre-season commences. That same question will face all seventeen current players serving WADA code violation suspensions.

That is, of course, where Malthouse comes into the picture. As a recently-departed AFL coach, he’s reasonably current with AFL fitness and skill levels. More importantly, he’s deeply experienced in managing a group of athletes to achieve and maintain a peak athletic, and mental, performance. Previously Malthouse-coached players in Eddie Betts and Jarrad Waite made significant contributions to other clubs in 2015, however two others, Troy Menzel and Chris Yarran, have both reportedly been considered well below the standard for AFL fitness at their new clubs in 2016.

In our view, the key consideration is providing a reasonable analogue for an AFL football club environment for the banned players until they can resume with Essendon in November. That includes scheduling their training sessions and devising drills to maintain their competitive skills, as far as practicable, arranging ancillary staff like dietitians, physios, masseuses and so on. None of the players are coaches-in-waiting, so they simply don't have the skills to organise their own training.

Thinking in those terms, the $1 million price tag is really quite reasonable.

Finally, Crowley will provide the Bombers brains trust with a template for managing the reintegration of their twelve suspended players for the 2017 pre-season. That might yet prove to be the most important piece in this whole puzzle.


Read More

Not missing score review

We're watching the Cats and Barcodes going around on the second weekend of preseason, and it just occurred to us that something is missing.

The concept of having every scoring decision correct  isn't a bad one, but when it means a minute or more of slow motion replay it becomes a needless distraction.

It has been noticeable (eventually) that the game is not being interrupted to check every close goal line decision. It took time to notice it was missing because it's rarely really necessary through the home and away season.

Let's just get rid of the distraction and let the goal umpires make their decision.



All, or nothing at all

According to The Age's chief football writer, "The embarrassing oversight that has seen Alastair Clarkson not once named the AFL's coach of the year has led to a policy change by the games's coaching body."

Why is it embarrassing? Sure, his team has won three AFL Premierships on the trot — a not insignificant achievement — but should a premiership automatically qualify Clarkson to win the award? Should Clarkson get the gong if the Hawks finish ninth this year, as some sort of compensation?

We checked on the AFLCA website and here is the current basis for coaches voting on their peers for this award:

Allan Jeans Senior Coach of the Year AwardThis award is in recognition of the best performed Senior Coach throughout the home and away season, having regard for current season's performance, available resources, player talent and team management.
And here are the winners since the inauguration of the award (with Premiership coaches identified):
2015 - Luke Beveridge (Western Bulldogs)
2014 - John Longmire (Sydney)
2013 - Ken Hinkley (Port Adelaide)
2012 - John Longmire (Sydney)  Premiership
2011 - John Worsfold (West Coast)
2010 - Michael Malthouse (Collingwood)  Premiership
2009 - Ross Lyon (St. Kilda)
2008 - Mark Thompson (Geelong)
2007 - Mark Thompson (Geelong)  Premiership
2006 - John Worsfold (West Coast)
2005 - Neil Craig (Adelaide)
2004 - Mark Williams (Port Adelaide)  Premiership
2003 - Paul Roos (Sydney)

Those last three criteria seem to be quite reasonable for assessing the best coach for the year. If the award is for the best-performed coach of the year, you'd choose the Premiership coach almost every year.

So, on the basis of the season's performance, available resources, player talent and team management, Luke Beveridge was chosen, by his peers, as the Coach of the Year.

It all seems perfectly logical and not even faintly embarrassing to us.

One week down

AussieRulesBlog has been lucky enough to see all but one of this first week's games via our pay-TV service. Our initial view that the game had changed has been vindicated.

These are practice games and most teams will be holding something in reserve. Nevertheless, the standard has been good mostly with all teams giving fans something to look forward to. For some it was a competitive quarter by a young group, for others a commanding win.

The key takeout is the change in tackling mentioned in a previous post. Interestingly, while catching the replay of the Brisbane–Gold Coast game tonight, Jonathan Brown and Cameron Mooney made the same point in commentary. In the past, they said, players were taught to try to hurt an opponent, by driving a shoulder into their ribs, or driving their opponent's shoulder into the turf. So far in 2016, we've noticed one fairly gentle 'sling'-type tackle. The tacklers' objectives seem to be simply to hold the ball carrier up and to try to win the holding the ball or incorrect disposal free kick. Old players are wistful for those 'harder' times, but we think this is an especially good development.

The other key thing we've taken note of is the attacking nature of the games, generally from both sides. There's nothing more than pride riding on the result, so there's no incentive for coaches to close these games up to stem scoreboard bleeding. It will be interesting to review the style of play in the first home and away round and see if the attacking style remains in vogue.

It's tough to look too closely at this week's games and extrapolate to a full season, but AussieRulesBlog thought the Tigers were the least impressive team. Their disposal was poor for a club that has aspirations to go deep into finals. They'll look better against teams less well-drilled than the Hawks, but our view of Richmond has long been that they reward mediocrity. This week's game did nothing to suggest they won't be afflicted with the same problem in 2016.

All in all, though, isn't it great to have some footy back?

A hard road for a giant

Much bleating on social media and elsewhere about the week’s holiday being offered to Docker giant, Aaron Sandilands, but the MRP are following a well-established practice.

Sandilands can’t be blamed for being head and shoulders above the rest of the competition, at least in stature, but he erred on two counts. Firstly, Griffiths wasn’t his ruck opponent, and second, having chosen to bump, he (Sandilands) bears the responsibility for even coincidental high contact or injury.

It must be hard being that tall. There are probably less than a handful of opponents he can legitimately decide to bump without being in danger of high contact.

It goes without saying that there will be MRP decisions that will perplex and mystify, but this isn't one of them. Enjoy your week off, Aaron.

A noticeable change

Watching the opening game of the 2016 pre-season tonight, one thing stood out — the change in tackling intention. It might be that the umpiring department have got onto something that will improve the game we watch every week.

In the lead-up to the game, it was made quite clear, though the media, that the umpires would strictly police slinging tackles. AussieRulesBlog sees that as a real plus, but we were prepared to be disappointed.

In recent years, the objective of tackling has seemed to be to force the opponent into the ground with as much force as could be mustered. Almost inevitably, we saw sling tackles and players, unable to protect or brace themselves, being slammed into the ground. A few concussions resulted in a so-called 'double movement' sling tackle becoming a reportable offence — but that didn't stop the intent to slam players into the turf.

Tonight's first pre-season game was played at a pretty good pace for a the first competitive practice game, with plenty of physical clashes. For all of that, the intention when tackling seemed to be to win a free kick for holding the ball or incorrect disposal, rather than to knock the opponent into next week. There were no sling-type tackles that we saw.

It was a refreshing change, and one that we hope to see repeated as we see more games.

There’s plenty for Blues fans to like from Brendan Bolton’s first outing as head coach, while Sam Mitchell looked not to have missed a beat from the Grand Final. It’s great to have footy back!

A not-so-steep price tag

At first glance, Mick Malthouse’s reported $1 million price tag to manage the twelve suspended Bombers (and three at other Melbourne clubs?) for the 2016 season is a steep one. If Paul Little steps in and picks up the tab, it's a no-brainer. But even if the players funded it themselves, there's more upside than down.


While there’s plenty of precedent for players missing a year of football and returning successfully, they’re generally within the bosom of their club, with all of the benefits, and psychological and social advantages, of team elan.

Those banned from their teams, and from competitive sport, for a year are far fewer — Ahmed Saad, Lachie Keefe, Josh Thomas and Ryan Crowley.

Saad had a one-year rookie contract with the Saints following his suspension, but was then delisted and not drafted by another AFL club. Keefe and Thomas have been listed as rookies for 2016 by the Barcodes following their year suspended. Crowley was set to resume his football in the WAFL after failing to be drafted following his year away from the game, but was the first player signed by Essendon when topping up their list after the CAS decision. (Being the first player signed was, in all likelihood, more a matter of availability than desirability.)

Saad’s career at AFL level appears to be finished. Keefe and Thomas will be playing VFL in 2016 and hoping for elevation to the senior list and a contract for 2017 and beyond — but nothing is certain. Only Crowley, courtesy of the unusual circumstances at Essendon, will have an immediate chance to put his case on-field for continuing his career.

It's hard to imagine that Dyson Heppell, for instance, won’t be welcomed back into the Bombers’ fold with open arms in 2017. The question will be how far below the Dyson Heppell of 2015 he’ll be in late 2016 when pre-season commences. That same question will face all seventeen current players serving WADA code violation suspensions.

That is, of course, where Malthouse comes into the picture. As a recently-departed AFL coach, he’s reasonably current with AFL fitness and skill levels. More importantly, he’s deeply experienced in managing a group of athletes to achieve and maintain a peak athletic, and mental, performance. Previously Malthouse-coached players in Eddie Betts and Jarrad Waite made significant contributions to other clubs in 2015, however two others, Troy Menzel and Chris Yarran, have both reportedly been considered well below the standard for AFL fitness at their new clubs in 2016.

In our view, the key consideration is providing a reasonable analogue for an AFL football club environment for the banned players until they can resume with Essendon in November. That includes scheduling their training sessions and devising drills to maintain their competitive skills, as far as practicable, arranging ancillary staff like dietitians, physios, masseuses and so on. None of the players are coaches-in-waiting, so they simply don't have the skills to organise their own training.

Thinking in those terms, the $1 million price tag is really quite reasonable.

Finally, Crowley will provide the Bombers brains trust with a template for managing the reintegration of their twelve suspended players for the 2017 pre-season. That might yet prove to be the most important piece in this whole puzzle.