The timing is in the luck of the draw

Last year, in the wake of drawn games in consecutive weeks, I commented on then-widespread calls for some means of breaking the draw in home and away matches.

This last weekend, we have two teams being coached by stand-in coaches — desperate for victories to enhance their chances at securing their role for 2010 and beyond — fighting out a thrilling draw. Not surprisingly, stand-in Richmond coach Jade Rawlings calls for a draw-breaking mechanism. Also not surprisingly, Patrick Smith, speaking on SEN radio, opines that there's a fundamental problem in having draws through the home-and-away season when there are draw-breaking mechanisms in place through the final series.

Rawlings position is understandable and sentimentally attractive — although the odds are his team would have lost. Smith's position is less understandable.

I, for one, don't understand why a draw is such a terrible result, especially when it's such a relative rarity. If we were discussing fudball, the situation is somewhat different with nil-all, or one-all draws commonplace.

For two aussie rules teams to find themselves on exactly the same points tally at the end of four quarters of hectic football is, and should be widely acknowledged as, a testament to the never-say-die courage and determination of two groups of athletes fighting each other to a standstill over an allotted period.

Far from seeking mechanisms to thwart draws, we should be celebrating these rare occurrences and lauding the athletes involved.

Watching the game on television from the comfort of my lounge chair, the excitement of the finish was almost stolen by the presence on the screen of a countdown clock. If not for the derring-do of Mitch Morton, the tension would have been gone from the game with more than 90 seconds still to play. Earlier this year, amid proposals to place countdown clocks on the main scoreboard, I challenged the rationale for countdown clocks. I am firmly of the view that countdown clocks should be banned full-stop — none in the media, none for the teams, none on the scoreboard.

Aussie rules audiences have suffered the tension of not knowing how long a quarter would run for a hundred or more years. Strategically, the game is different if you know exactly how much time is left, and it's UGLY.

Lets remove ALL countdown clocks. There's nothing to be gained and many moments of heart-rending tension to be experienced.